West Lindsey District Council lodged plans for a £6.3 million leisure centre in Market Rasen despite calls from campaigners for an additional swimming pool.
Dubbed a “dry leisure facility”, the move comes as part of a wider investment of £7.8 million in facilities across the district.
But campaigners said a swimming pool was a “higher priority”.
The new facility would be built off Gainsborough Road in the village and will include a 3G pitch, fitness and dance suite, as well as a sports hall.
Meanwhile, the council said Everyone Active will run the centre after leaving their current site at Aston Sports Centre.
Market Rasen Town councillors have said the centre is a “fantastic opportunity for the area.
Yet campaigners from Market Rasen Action Group lodged a 2,000 signature petition to the district council opposing the plans.
The group called on the authority to build a swimming pool in the town.
Recently-elected Rasen town councillor and group secretary June Clark told the district council that residents had not been consulted on the plans.
She said: “Residents were understandably very upset that there had been no consultation about the new facility and the fact there was no mention of a swimming pool.
“Although we agree that dry facilities are needed, a swimming pool is seen as a higher priority.”
However, councillors rejected the petition and council leader Jeff Summers said the proposal would require “significant subsidy”.
He added that a consultation had taken place and that a pool would be “unsustainable”.
The application for the leisure centre will be decided by the local authority at a later date.
SUBSCRIBE TO LOCAL DEMOCRACY WEEKLY, our exclusive email newsletter with highlights from our coverage every week and insights and analysis from our local democracy reporters.